The strike hit the hospital complex in Khan Younis, southern Gaza, after midnight. Israel's account focused on the target and the military activity it said took place inside. Hospital administrators described damage to the surgical wing and interruption of medical services. The accounts do not establish an agreed explanation of the circumstances.
The Military Identifies the Brigade Commander
The initial Israeli announcement said a senior terrorist and additional operatives hiding inside the complex had been targeted. The IDF and Shin Bet subsequently identified the senior figure as Muhammad Abu Ismail, commander of the terrorist organization Hamas's Khan Younis Brigade.
According to the military, Abu Ismail directed brigade members in planning and carrying out attacks against Israeli troops and civilians. It also accused him of responsibility for holding numerous hostages during the war.
The IDF said the operatives had turned part of the hospital compound into a headquarters used to prepare attacks and restore the brigade's capabilities. The military supplied the target's identity and description of his role; announcing that he was targeted does not confirm he was killed.
Claims About Activity Inside the Complex
The IDF and Shin Bet accused Hamas of using the hospital for command and control, weapons storage, observation and shelter. They also alleged that interrogations and torture took place there. They said the strike was intended to remove the threat posed by operatives at the site.
Hamas rejected Israel's account of the activity inside the hospital and condemned the attack. The intelligence underlying the targeting decision was not published in full, leaving the competing claims about the site's use attributed to their respective sources.
Israel's statement addressed a commander and operatives it said were present. It did not establish that everyone harmed was a Hamas member or provide a complete casualty list matching the targets to the medical account.
A Surgeon and a Boy Among Reported Deaths
Gaza's Health Ministry identified surgeon Dr. Rizk Abu Shaira among the six people killed, alongside at least two patients, including a 13 year old boy. Medical officials also reported numerous injuries. Counts varied during the day, with later reporting giving at least 28 wounded.
British surgeon Goher Rahbour, who was volunteering at the hospital, said he had operated alongside Abu Shaira hours before the strike. He described an explosion that shook the building and severe damage to a recovery area on the floor where he was staying.
Hospital director Ahmed al-Farra said surgery and other services had been suspended because of the damage. He said nearby facilities could not perform some of the specialized operations Nasser provided. Those descriptions came from hospital management and medical staff.
Different Accounts of Warnings
The IDF said it took measures to reduce civilian harm, including precision munitions and aerial surveillance. It also said it had warned on several occasions, including recently, that military activity at the hospital must stop.
Al-Farra said there was no warning before the strike. Previous demands to end military activity and an immediate warning of an impending attack are not necessarily the same communication. The published accounts do not establish that staff and patients received an evacuation notice for this strike.
The US backed Board of Peace called for Israel and Hamas to honor their ceasefire commitments. World Health Organization director general Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said health facilities must neither be militarized nor attacked. In the November 12 reporting reviewed, the target's condition and complete consequences of the strike had not been clarified in a final Israeli statement.