Skip to content
Politics & Diplomacy

Ohana Sets Knesset Speaker Vote for November 17

The Knesset is scheduled to debate and vote on its next speaker on Tuesday, November 17, at 4 p.m. Amir Ohana announced the date on November 10 after receiving a request signed by 67 lawmakers. He criticized the initiative but said he would respect the majority's wishes. The vote has not taken place, and no new speaker has been elected through it.

Ohana Sets Knesset Speaker Vote for November 17
Lectern Facing Empty Seats · Disclaimer

The signatures gave the request the backing of a parliamentary majority, but do not replace the vote. Nor do they show that all signatories agree on the next government or its legislative programme. The approaching decision concerns the leadership of parliament while coalition negotiations continue.

A Vote at the Opening of the Sitting

Ohana's announcement provides for a debate when the November 17 plenary sitting opens, followed by a vote. The scheduled date is one week after he announced receipt of the request from the 67 members.

Matan Kahana is the change bloc's candidate for speaker. Agreement on his candidacy is not an appointment, and scheduling the vote does not guarantee its outcome. Lawmakers will still have to cast their votes in the chamber.

Ohana continues in office under the continuity arrangements between the outgoing and incoming Knessets. Those arrangements allow parliament to function before a permanent speaker is elected. They do not require the new election to wait until coalition negotiations are complete.

Parliament Can Choose Before a Government Is Formed

Section 2(b) of the Knesset Rules of Procedure requires the speaker to be elected no later than the sitting at which a government is formed. If both decisions are scheduled for the same sitting, the speaker must be elected first. That establishes a latest stage, rather than prohibiting an earlier election.

A 2020 High Court ruling, referenced in a note accompanying the rules, also addresses a speaker serving under continuity arrangements. It requires that parliament be allowed to elect a permanent speaker when a majority of its members demands it.

The practical distinction is between temporary continuity in office and the new parliament's right to choose its leadership. Electing a speaker is not a confidence vote in a government and does not create a governing coalition that has yet to be negotiated.

Ohana described the request for an early election as unusual. Citing press reports, he argued that it was intended to advance legislation expanding the attorney general's powers and worsening what he viewed as an imbalance between elected officials and the professional establishment.

That was Ohana's political assessment of the initiative's purpose. The scheduling announcement is not a bill and does not itself alter the attorney general's authority. Any such change would require a separate legislative process.

Despite his opposition, Ohana said he would act in accordance with the wishes of most lawmakers. His statement separated his criticism of their intentions from the parliamentary procedure they had requested.

The Decision Still Lies Ahead

The speaker chairs plenary proceedings, maintains order and observance of parliamentary rules, and represents the Knesset externally. Choosing the officeholder therefore matters even before a new cabinet is formed: the legislature does not begin its work only after coalition agreements are signed.

At the same time, choosing a speaker does not approve every bill that the speaker's supporters may later pursue. Each proposal must follow the applicable process, and different votes may produce different combinations of support and opposition.

The announced next step is the November 17 sitting, beginning at 4 p.m. Israel time. The result will be determined in the chamber, rather than by the signatures or statements preceding it.

Even if a new speaker is elected at that sitting, government formation will remain a separate process. Both are taking place within the newly elected Knesset, but each requires decisions of its own.

The party leaders said committee memberships would be developed through the Arrangements Committee and submitted for approval. They also announced agreement on establishing special committees, without giving a full account of their membership or responsibilities in that statement.

Parliament Can Act Before a Government Is Formed

The Knesset does not need to wait for coalition negotiations to end before beginning work. It can elect a speaker, establish appropriate committees, advance legislation and scrutinize the government that continues in office. The legislature and the executive are separate institutions.

The speaker and deputy speakers have an important role in organizing the plenary agenda. The Arrangements Committee manages parliamentary organization at the beginning of a term and later proposes the composition of permanent committees. Temporary finance and foreign affairs and defense committees can operate before those permanent bodies are established.

That gives the nominations immediate significance. They concern the institutions through which debates, oversight and votes proceed while the next government's composition remains unsettled. Control of these positions does not, however, remove legislative requirements or guarantee support for every bill.

Legislative Plans Still Require Legislative Decisions

The bloc is pursuing plans to reverse changes affecting the judicial system, including the Judicial Selection Committee, alongside measures concerning communications and the attorney general's powers. These are political objectives. Agreement on parliamentary officeholders does not repeal any law by itself.

The next steps are scheduling the speaker election, approving committee compositions and selecting officeholders under the procedures for each body. Government formation talks continue on a separate track. That separation is the central development: parliamentary organization can advance even while an agreement on the next government remains out of reach.

Back to Latest News

Choose which optional content this site may load. You can change this at any time from the Cookie Settings link at the bottom of the page.

Necessary

Remembers your cookie and accessibility choices in your browser. Always on.

Allows audience measurement tools to load, if this site uses them.

Allows content from other services, such as embedded social media posts, to load. These services may set their own cookies.

This site shows ads from Google AdSense. Allowing this lets Google use cookies to show ads based on your interests. Without it, you see non-personalized ads.

Accessibility

Text size 100%

Settings are saved in this browser.